The best platform for performance email marketing is the one whose revenue number you can read and check. Performance marketing judges each channel by the sales it brings in, so that number is what email gets judged on.
Fewer than half of companies track it, according to Litmus's research on email returns:
- 41% attribute revenue directly to email marketing campaigns
- 59% analyze engagement metrics such as opens, click rate and bounce rate
So the revenue report is the place to judge a platform, and ActiveCampaign comes first on that test.
Its revenue reporting starts on Plus and higher plans. On the Pro plan, the window (how many days after an email a sale still counts) can stretch to 365 days.
- ActiveCampaign, for teams that want a revenue number they can check without an enterprise price
- Klaviyo, for stores that want to set their own window
- Mailchimp, for small stores with a connected shop
- HubSpot, for teams on Marketing Hub Enterprise that want several ways to split credit
| Platform | Revenue reporting starts on (price a month at 10,000 contacts) | Days after the email a sale still counts, by default |
|---|---|---|
| ActiveCampaign | Plus, $239 (revenue report). Pro, $419 (attribution report) | 7 after the send. Attribution report adjustable to 365 |
| Klaviyo | No plan named in Klaviyo's help article. Email plan, $150 | 5 after an open or click. Adjustable |
| Mailchimp | Standard, $135, with a connected store | 5 after an open, 30 after a click. Adjustable |
| HubSpot | Enterprise, from $3,600 with 10,000 contacts, plus $7,000 onboarding | Not published. Counts clicks only |
HubSpot's price comes from its own page, which doesn't say how it's billed. The other prices are EmailToolTester's monthly rates as updated on August 5, 2026.
For features beyond revenue reporting, see this email marketing software comparison.
The best platforms for performance email marketing
All four email service providers here report email revenue, but each counts a sale its own way. Before you pick a platform for email campaign management, check each one for:
- The plan its revenue report starts on
- Anything you must connect first, such as a store
- How many days a sale still counts, and whether that starts at the send, open or click
- Which orders and clicks the count leaves out
ActiveCampaign, Klaviyo and Mailchimp use last touch, which gives all the credit to the last email a person opened or clicked before buying. Bot activity (opens and clicks no person made) can inflate that count.
Apple Mail Privacy Protection is an Apple Mail setting that hides whether a person opened an email.
Bot clicks are clicks made by security software as it scans links. Validity says corporate systems and email gateways routinely scan links, which can trigger bot clicks.
1. ActiveCampaign, for revenue you can check without an enterprise price
ActiveCampaign comes first because it reports email revenue on Plus and lets you stretch the window to 365 days on Pro. At 10,000 contacts, EmailToolTester lists Plus at $239 a month and Pro at $419.
Its marketing attribution reports split the job between the Marketing Revenue report and the Conversion Attribution report:
- Plan: Plus for the revenue report and Pro for the attribution report, per ActiveCampaign pricing
- Window: 7 days after the send for the revenue report, and 7 days by default for attribution (adjustable to 14, 30, 90, 180 or 365)
- Credit: the most recently opened campaign gets the revenue from a buyer who opened or clicked, and the attribution report uses last touch
- Left out: canceled, refunded, returned and failed orders, in the revenue report
The revenue report subtracts discounts from Shopify orders but not from WooCommerce or BigCommerce ones. It shows one currency at a time and lists only the top five automation emails and top five campaigns by revenue.
ActiveCampaign's BotSense filters bot clicks and opens out of its analytics and reporting once an admin turns it on. It's off by default and doesn't change past data, so turn it on before you run a test.
Best for: teams that want revenue reporting and an adjustable window without an enterprise price.
Skip if: you sell in more than one currency and want one revenue total, or you run WooCommerce or BigCommerce and need revenue after discounts.
2. Klaviyo, for stores that want to set their own window
Klaviyo lets you set the window yourself and decide whether bot activity counts toward email sales. Its help article on attribution sets out the rules:
- Plan: the article doesn't tie attribution to a plan, and only a few extras need certain add-ons
- Window: 5 days after an open or click by default, and you can change it
- Credit: all of it to the last email opened or clicked
- Left out: bot clicks and what Klaviyo calls "Apple Privacy opens", once you choose to remove them
Changing a setting recalculates past attribution, which can take up to 36 hours.
The Email plan is $150 a month at 10,000 active profiles (Klaviyo's name for contacts), per EmailToolTester. Klaviyo's own pricing page shows only $20 a month for 500 active profiles. For a side-by-side, see ActiveCampaign vs Klaviyo.
Best for: stores that want to set their own window and keep bot activity out of the sales count.
Skip if: you want sales credited on clicks alone without changing settings, since an open within 5 days counts by default.
3. Mailchimp, for small stores with a connected shop
Mailchimp gives clicks a longer window than opens and filters bots from the start, but its revenue dashboard needs a connected store. Its Conversion Insights dashboard and attribution help page set the rules:
- Plan: Standard or higher, with a connected e-commerce store
- Window: 5 days after an open or 30 days after a click
- Credit: the last email before the order
- Left out: Apple Mail Privacy Protection, email providers' anti-spam security and link preview tools, through bot filtering that's on by default
You can change the defaults on the Manage Integration page of your e-commerce app.
Bot filtering applies to the whole account, so you can't set it for one report.
Standard is $135 a month at 10,000 contacts, per EmailToolTester. Mailchimp's own pricing page offers 15% off the first 12 months for 10,000 contacts or more. For a side-by-side, see ActiveCampaign vs Mailchimp.
Best for: small stores with a connected shop that want bot filtering on from the start.
Skip if: you don't sell through a connected store, or you want any model other than last touch.
4. HubSpot, for teams already on Marketing Hub Enterprise
HubSpot filters bot activity by default on every plan, but it ties email to revenue only on Marketing Hub Enterprise. Its bot filter and revenue attribution work like this:
- Plan: Enterprise for revenue attribution and email-to-order reporting, which also needs Shopify connected through Data Sync
- Window: none published in HubSpot's attribution article
- Credit: an email counts only if it went to the contact's primary address and they clicked a link in it
- Left out: suspected bot activity (Apple Mail Privacy Protection included), on every plan by default
Revenue attribution offers nine ways to split credit. Some give all of it to the first or last interaction, and others share it across several.
A sent email's report shows opens and clicks with and without bot activity, and you can turn the filter off in tracking code settings.
Enterprise starts at $3,600 a month with 10,000 marketing contacts, plus a one-time $7,000 onboarding fee. For a side-by-side, see ActiveCampaign vs HubSpot.
Best for: teams already on Marketing Hub Enterprise that want several ways to split credit.
Skip if: you need revenue attribution without an Enterprise budget.
Email marketing metrics that hold up better than open rate
Revenue shows what an email earned, and open rate is now the least reliable of your key performance indicators. Litmus argues that revenue marks a high-performing email, whatever its opens.
| Metric | What it tells you | What can skew it |
|---|---|---|
| Open rate | Who opened the email, or seemed to | Apple Mail Privacy Protection (on for over 50% of opens), Gmail loading images early (up to 2 percentage points, by Sparkpost's estimate) and security tools opening mail |
| Click rate | Who clicked a link | Security scanners that follow links, which create bot clicks |
| Click-to-open rate | Clicks divided by opens | The same things that skew open rate |
| Conversion rate | Who bought after the email | The window, which differs by platform (5 to 30 days by default for ActiveCampaign, Klaviyo and Mailchimp) |
| Revenue per email | Revenue divided by emails delivered | The same orders credited by several systems, plus the kind of email, store and order size, as Bluecore observes |
Clicks hold up better. Apple says Mail Privacy Protection doesn't extend to links, so its hidden opens leave your click rate alone.
Security tools can still click, though. GetResponse writes that bots and tools scanning emails for security or previews can inflate both open and click statistics.
So track revenue for the whole program and for each send:
- Whole program: Bluecore suggests tracking annualized attributed revenue growth, using month-over-month data. That's the yearly growth rate of the revenue credited to email.
- Each send: judge it on conversion rate and revenue per email, whether it's a one-off campaign or part of your email marketing automation.
Tests work the same way. For A/B testing emails, Litmus suggests judging subject lines by click rate or conversion rate.
Use audience segmentation to keep each audience separate, since you can't tell which send drove a sale when the same people sit on two lists.
Whatever your email marketing strategies are, review every campaign after it sends. Shifali Jamwal, Senior Product Marketing Manager at ActiveCampaign, says marketers skip this step.
"Sending something and then never doing a retrospective on what worked and what didn't work. That is every marketer's weakness, because everyone is so, 'let's do more,' rather than, 'let's do efficiently.'" Shifali Jamwal
Email marketing analytics that line up with Google Analytics 4
Your marketing automation platform and Google Analytics 4 (GA4) will rarely show the same email revenue. GA4 credits email only for clicks tagged as email, and it looks back much further than the platforms do.
Bloomreach sells attribution software, and it writes that GA4 can count only email clicks that arrive tagged. It adds that untagged clicks from mail apps often show up as direct or referral traffic.
To read the two numbers correctly, take these steps:
- Tag every link. Add UTM parameters (tags that tell analytics where a click came from) to each link and set the medium to "email". GA4's default channel group files a visit under Email when its source or medium is "email". If you use ActiveCampaign, see its Google Analytics integration.
- Don't expect the two numbers to match. GA4's lookback window is how far back it looks for a visit to credit. It's 90 days for most key events (the actions you track) and 30 days for first visits. ActiveCampaign, Klaviyo and Mailchimp use 5 to 30 days by default.
- Keep the totals apart. Don't add your platform's email revenue to other reports, because Bloomreach says several systems credit the same orders. Report each system's number on its own.
- Hold out a group. A holdout group is a random share of customers who get no email. Compare their revenue per customer with everyone else's. The holdout shows what customers would have bought anyway, so the gap is what email added.
GA4 also splits credit its own way. Its three attribution models are Data-driven, Paid and organic last click, and Google paid channels last click. Google dropped the first click, linear, time decay and position-based models in November 2023.
Email marketing benchmarks and how far to trust them
Publishers' average open rates land in the 30s. A 35% open rate is about the average email open rate.
It's a little under the 39.26% in ActiveCampaign's email benchmarks and level with Mailchimp's 35.63%. It's also above the 31% Klaviyo calls good for campaigns.
| Publisher | Open rate it reports | Click rate it reports | Period the data covers |
|---|---|---|---|
| ActiveCampaign | 39.26% average | 6.21% average | Campaigns sent January 1 to December 10, 2025 (click rate for 2025) |
| Mailchimp | 35.63% for all users | 2.62% for all users | Data as of December 2023 |
| Klaviyo | 31% for campaigns, which it calls good | 1.69% for campaigns, which it calls good | Not published |
The averages differ by publisher, date and who's counted, and Mailchimp's are nearly three years old. Klaviyo's come from over 183,000 customers but carry no date.
Because Apple Mail Privacy Protection and bots inflate opens, compare each send with your own past sends on click rate and revenue. Your history measures the same list the same way each time.
Revenue benchmarks say more. Litmus's 2025 State of Email report found that for every $1 spent on email, marketing leaders get back:
- $10 to $36, for 35% of them
- $36 to $50, for 30%
- More than $50, for 5%
That's 70% of marketing leaders getting at least $10 back for each $1. Litmus also found that 21% of marketing leaders didn't measure email ROI (return on investment) in 2025, down from 36% in 2023.
Klaviyo splits campaigns from flows (its name for automations), and reports that flows' revenue per recipient is nearly 18 times campaigns'.
Log click rate and revenue for each send, or start with the email performance calculator.
Frequently asked questions
What are some examples of performance marketing?
Salesforce defines performance marketing as a digital marketing strategy where advertisers pay only when a set action happens, such as a sale or a click. It names these performance marketing channels:
- Paid search
- Social media advertising
- Native ads
- Affiliate marketing
Salesforce's full list also includes email marketing and influencer marketing, though it says most email platforms don't offer pay-per-conversion billing.
Email fits when you judge it on the same results, using key performance indicators such as sales and clicks you can count.
What is the 60/40 rule in email?
The 60/40 rule has two meanings, and neither comes from an industry body. Mailpro uses it for your mix of emails, with about 60% value-first and 40% promotional.
Unanswered.io uses it for design, with at least 60% text and no more than 40% images. If you follow the mix version, check it against your own revenue per email.
What is the 3-3-3 rule for marketing?
Lyfe Marketing defines it as three main messages, three customer groups and three channels. A similar rule of thirds splits a content mix into educational, promotional and entertaining pieces.
The rule has no official source. For email, treat it as a way to plan your segments. It won't tell you whether a send paid off.